.
Feedback

No Charges Filed in Hit and Run Case; Arraignment Delayed Until June

Spencer Freeman Smith, the San Ramon lawyer arrested in connection with last week's hit-and-run, made his first court appearance on Tuesday.

Spencer Freeman Smith has plenty of experience inside a courtroom but not in the role he played on Tuesday — defendant.

The San Ramon lawyer, who was in connection with the fatal hit-and-run on Dougherty Road in Dublin, appeared in court for the first time Tuesday morning.

Wearing a navy suit, Smith stood in front of the judge at the  in Pleasanton for about a minute, but didn't say anything except for a few whispered words to his lawyer.

Charges weren't filed and no plea was entered, with the arraignment hearing being pushed back until June 27. Smith is currently out on bail.

"Police are still investigating the case and no charges have been filed yet," Teresa Drenick of the Alameda District Attorney's Office said.

Smith is being represented by Bill Gagen, a long-time Bay Area trial attorney. Gagen's biography page on his firm's website quotes a 2003 San Francisco Chronicle article that says, "If you get in trouble with the law in Contra Costa, who do you call? Those in the know say it’s Bill Gagen."

"I think there are two issues in this case," Gagen told reporters after the hearing.

"First, how did the accident happen? What was someone doing in the middle of a busy intersection at 11:30 at night? Would any driver expect someone to be there?"

"Second, what did my client know and when did he know it?"

Gagen said Smith feels terrible and is devastated about the death of Bo Hu, the man killed in the hit-and-run last Tuesday. Citing attorney-client privilege, Gagen said he could not comment on why Smith didn't stop after the collision or why he didn't alert police immediately.

On Monday, a private funeral for Hu was held at  in Dubin.

Elizabeth May 22, 2012 at 08:37 pm
Typical disgusting lawyer-speak, casting the innocent person killed as the one being in the wrong with the quote -- "What was someone doing in the middle of a busy intersection at 11:30 at night?"
What was the Mercedes driving attorney doing out at 11:30 at night himself, never stopping after he ran into this person, never calling 911 or even bothering to stop? Then hiding his Merc in the garage.
Pleasanton Mom May 22, 2012 at 10:25 pm
Can someone who understands all this legal stuff please explain what happens now? Why no charges? Does this mean they don't have enough evidence and this guy might get off? Or is it simply a process thing? I'm all about due process, but I can't imagine how he could get away without at least being charged and put on trial when he purposely hid the car even when he knew he killed someone when it hit the media. Even if he says he thought he hit a deer, if he had nothing to hide he would have immediately come forward and it might have been considered an accident. Something is wrong here when he hides the car, doesn't come forward and immediately lawyer's up.
I'd love to understand what happens now from anyone on here that cares enough to explain to lay people like me.
Pleasanton Mom May 22, 2012 at 10:27 pm
P.S. the lawyer is an idiot. Is he trying to say that his client has more of a right to be on this public road than a bike rider or anyone else for that matter? Is this client special or something? If I had to guess, he was drunk.
Patrick Creaven (Editor) May 22, 2012 at 11:19 pm
Hi Lisa. To put simply, Dublin police are still investigating the incident. They will show their evidence to the Alameda County District Attorney's Office. The DA will then decide what Smith should be charged with and make it official on June 27. Unless something between now and then changes.
Longtime Resident May 22, 2012 at 11:20 pm
No, he hasn't been charged yet because the investigation isn't complete. Nothing at all unusual for a fatal hit and run. The DA will wait for the police report to be complete, lab results matching hair/fibers/DNA from the victim to the vehicle, etc. Nothing to worry about, it's simply a procedural thing.
Pleasanton Mom May 23, 2012 at 12:00 am
Thanks for explaining things Patrick and LR. I was a bit worried this meant the case wasn't strong enough or something. Feeling much better after reading your posts. Thanks again.
Patricia May 23, 2012 at 02:29 pm
I second that Elizabeth , the lawyer is an idiot what intersection is that busy @ 11:30 at night that you could not see a bike or know that you hit something!!!! He had to be under the influence ? Any one in there right mind would stop to see what they hit ;( so sad for the family RIP
Concerned Citizen May 23, 2012 at 03:22 pm
I agree that Mr. Smith was likely under the influence and that's why he didn't stop. I guess he figured hit and run was better than DUI...

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from San Ramon Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something